Airbnb vs. Resort: What Are the Professionals and Cons of Every?

It’s the final word battle royale: Airbnb vs. lodge. Each avid and occasional vacationers know that the selection is usually a tough one. Particularly once we journey someplace new, there’s a whole lot of strain to seek out the correct lodging for our particular needs and desires.

To take a few of that strain off, right here’s a breakdown of the professionals and cons of Airbnb vs. lodge stays, together with concerns similar to security, worth, and total high quality:

Professionals of Airbnb

A stunning Airbnb in Joshua Tree

Alternatives to fulfill locals

Staying in a non-public room in somebody’s dwelling by Airbnb is usually a nice alternative to fulfill locals, if that’s what you’re hoping to do. When Airbnb first launched, the platform was extra like a paid model of Couchsurfing. Hosts would obtain company of their properties, who would hire a room at a fraction of the price of a lodge. Once I first used Airbnb in 2017 (I used to be a bit of late to the sport, I do know), this was my expertise. I stayed in Bogotá with a beautiful couple of artists who even confirmed me across the metropolis and invited me out to drinks with their buddies.

The platform has modified loads since then, with increasingly choices to hire whole locations. You may nonetheless hire a room in somebody’s dwelling like to start with, however extra usually individuals search for a extra personal keep.

General, it may be toss-up if you happen to select to hire a room, as a result of likelihood is you’ll work together much more together with your host. I’ve had nice experiences with this, and others that have been simply “meh.”

May be extra reasonably priced than lodges

This isn’t at all times true for each vacation spot, however in lots of locations world wide, Airbnb presents less expensive lodging that provide you with a much bigger bang to your buck. Generally once I journey round Mexico, for instance, I’ll examine costs at lodges to Airbnbs, and nearly at all times Airbnbs find yourself less expensive, even in spite of everything the additional charges.

Sometimes, personal rooms in a shared dwelling are the most affordable possibility on Airbnb. These both have a non-public or shared toilet, plus entry to frequent areas, similar to the lounge and kitchen. It’s additionally doable to seek out utterly personal rooms, suites, and whole flats on Airbnb which are cheaper than a lodge room.

Extra distinctive choices (glamping, treehouses, and so forth.)

Lately, Airbnb has leveled up its choice of distinctive stays. Now you’ll find glamping choices, treehouses, yurts, Airstreams, and extra on the platform. Locations like these may be laborious to come back by if you happen to don’t know the place else to look, so Airbnb offers vacationers the chance to seek out them extra simply — there’s even a search characteristic that means that you can zero in on such distinctive stays.

Cozy environments with the comforts of dwelling

It is a big plus for me, as I like the thought of staying in a house somewhat than a sterile lodge room that appears precisely the identical as every other. Since Airbnb means that you can keep in a number’s precise residence, usually you’ll be greeted by their distinctive decorations and homey touches. This additionally offers you a glimpse into how individuals in a given place stay, which may be attention-grabbing.

Extra sensible for longer stays (greater than per week)

Since there are listings for whole flats with full kitchens on Airbnb, the platform is far more best for longer stays than a typical lodge. Having a kitchen, which is sort of unparalleled for a lodge, means that you can do your individual grocery buying and put together meals as an alternative of counting on eating places. In case you’re staying someplace longer than per week, consuming solely at eating places can get costly, so having a kitchen may be an effective way to save cash and even keep wholesome.

Staying in additional off-the-beaten-path places

airbnb vs. hotel

I like that you’ll find Airbnbs nearly wherever on the earth, even in some fairly distant locations. I as soon as stayed in an Airbnb in Guatemala that was on part of Lake Atitlán that doesn’t obtain almost as a lot tourism as different areas. Essentially the most pleasing a part of it was being off the vacationer observe and having my very own little nook of the lake.

On Airbnb, you possibly can see a map of the properties in a given space. Though the precise places aren’t at all times tremendous correct to the map, the characteristic means that you can get a greater thought of how distant the place is. Many small cities or locations in nature won’t have lodges, so Airbnb means that you can discover lodging the place you in any other case wouldn’t have the ability to.

Extra potential for privateness

This clearly doesn’t apply if you happen to keep in a non-public bed room in a shared home, however typically Airbnb presents extra potential for privateness. Since you possibly can select a complete home on the platform, for instance, you wouldn’t have to fret about sharing a wall with noisy neighbors.

Cons of Airbnb

airbnb vs. hotel

Checking in is usually a trouble

Making an attempt to coordinate your check-in with an Airbnb host may be difficult. Generally hosts will meet you to present you keys to the place, and typically they’ll depart keys in a lockbox. I favor the latter, because it takes the strain off of needing to reach at a sure time to fulfill the host. You gained’t know which check-in scenario you’ve gotten till you e-book, however most hosts have a system in place for very late or early check-ins. (This isn’t for certain, although.)

Unpredictable high quality

What number of instances have you ever fallen in love with a spot on Airbnb solely to seek out that it seems means completely different than the images? This sort of Airbnb catfishing is admittedly annoying, however it’s, sadly, a actuality that many company face.

There are methods to seek out out if the photographs of a spot don’t stay as much as the in-person expertise. First, verify the critiques. Often, prior company will level this out if it’s that apparent. It’s also possible to ship a message to a number earlier than you e-book to ask for extra present footage. They gained’t at all times have the ability to do that, however it’s price a shot.

Additionally, if the value appears too good to be true, it most likely is. Verify across the space on Airbnb to see how the place compares to others with the identical worth level. If yours seems means nicer than the others, the photographs is perhaps deceptive.

Potential for awkward host interactions

Fortuitously, I haven’t had too many awkward encounters with Airbnb hosts, however it does occur. Particularly if you happen to’re staying in a non-public room in somebody’s dwelling, you’re subjected to their rhythm of life, and it won’t be the moment friendship that you simply imagined. What in case your host has company over throughout your keep? What if they’ve kids or pets? Be sure to learn the total description of the place earlier than you e-book, to get a really feel to your host.

I are usually fairly optimistic about these conditions, however it’s necessary to think about what sort of expertise you need to have whereas touring so you possibly can resolve if it is smart to hire a non-public room in somebody’s dwelling.

Hosts can cancel on the final minute

Hosts can cancel reservations at any second previous to check-in, which is one thing that doesn’t often occur with lodges. Though this has by no means occurred to me, I’ve heard horror tales about vacationers getting left within the mud after their Airbnb host canceled their reserving on the final minute. Think about arriving in a brand new nation late at night time after a protracted flight, solely to understand that you simply now have nowhere to remain.

The platform has tons of controversy

Airbnb has been underneath hearth in recent times for a few causes. To begin with, individuals closely criticize the platform for being liable for gentrification in varied cities. Property house owners can snatch up low-cost flats, spruce them up, and hire them on Airbnb for a lot larger charges than the typical worth within the neighborhood. This could drive up rents, pushing out residents who can now not afford to stay there. It’s an advanced challenge that’s too advanced to sum up utterly, however there are many articles like this one from Forbes that discover Airbnb’s influence on gentrification.

Airbnb additionally confronted controversy in recent times when a number of individuals got here ahead accusing the platform of selling racial discrimination. Since then, Airbnb has promised to mitigate the bias, though the dangerous press actually tarnished its popularity.

It’s as much as each traveler to resolve if these controversies are dealbreakers by way of utilizing the platform, particularly if you wish to accomplish that as ethically as doable. Simply remember the fact that these points aren’t unique to Airbnb and could possibly be true for different lodging or companies.

Is Airbnb Secure?

airbnb vs. hotel

Airbnb is a good reserving website with a usually constructive security popularity. Personally, I’ve by no means felt unsafe in an Airbnb, whether or not I used to be renting a non-public room in a shared dwelling or a complete place. Some vacationers specific concern about reserving by Airbnb, nonetheless, as a result of they’re uncertain about whether or not or not they will belief their host. It is a legitimate concern, as you’re basically placing your belief in a stranger.

One method to keep protected whereas utilizing Airbnb is to make use of the Superhost filter, which solely exhibits you hosts which have earned a Superhost badge for upholding Airbnb’s highest requirements. It’s additionally at all times a good suggestion to take a look at the critiques of hosts’ listings to see if different vacationers suggest them. I additionally suggest speaking solely by way of Airbnb messages, simply in case something goes incorrect, in order that it’s simpler to report any host misconduct.

Professionals of Accommodations

If partitions may speak, what would they are saying on the US’s most haunted lodge, the Mizpah?

You will discover neat lodges with a whole lot of historical past

Whereas Airbnb has solely been round for under a bit of over a decade, there are lodges world wide which have actually a whole bunch of years of historical past inside their partitions. Locations just like the Mizpah Resort in Nevada are historic and cultural relics, with a long time and a long time of hospitality expertise. Staying at these sorts of lodges is an expertise all by itself, which is tougher to seek out on Airbnb.

Verify-in is less complicated

Overlook having to coordinate getting your keys together with your host. Checking in at lodges is a lot simpler, as a result of you possibly can present up everytime you’d like. In case you’re early, there’s often someplace close to the entrance desk the place you possibly can depart your baggage when you wait to your room to be prepared. That is commonplace apply at most lodges, however fairly uncommon for Airbnbs.

The concierge is there that can assist you

Go for lodges that serve a la carte breakfasts: one other lodge perk. This one’s from Bali.

If one thing in your lodge room is damaged or not working correctly, the concierge is there that can assist you straight away. This isn’t essentially the case for Airbnbs, as there’s no assure that your host will have the ability to repair a leaky sink or clogged drain, forcing you to take care of it at some stage in your keep. Accommodations specialise in hospitality in ways in which Airbnb hosts often don’t, which means the service is usually higher and extra well timed.

Extra correct photographs and predictable high quality

It might be far more tough for a lodge to catfish potential company with unrealistic photographs, as they’ve far more on the road if their company catch them within the act. The entire lodge and even the entire chain may go down in the event that they lie in regards to the high quality of their rooms, whereas an Airbnb host doesn’t have as a lot to lose.

Although there is perhaps some discrepancies between the polished {and professional} photographs of a lodge room and its precise high quality, lodges are often far more predictable in the case of high quality. You realize you’ll have clear sheets and gained’t discover any surprises within the drawers of the bedside tables, as a result of the lodge has an entire cleansing crew. With Airbnb, the standard and cleanliness can range drastically from host to host, and also you don’t actually know what you’re going to get till you arrive.

Extra security assurance

Accommodations often have safety cameras of their hallways and lobbies, and outdoors of the constructing. If there have been any form of security threat at your lodge, likelihood is it will be caught on tape. This may give vacationers peace of thoughts to know that there’s an additional layer of accountability.

Some lodges even have personal safety on the premise, and infrequently employees on the entrance desk 24/7, so there’s at all times somebody there that can assist you if you happen to really feel unsafe. The identical isn’t true for Airbnbs. Positive, you possibly can let your host know if one thing is incorrect, however there’s no assure that they’ll have the option that can assist you out at that precise second.

Cons of Accommodations

Accommodations in Bora Bora are lovely, however positively on the expensive aspect.

Probably much less privateness

The shoebox-y really feel of some lodges is a little bit of a turn-off for me, as a result of I don’t love that typically you possibly can hear your next-door neighbors. This isn’t at all times the case, however some cheaper lodges have very skinny partitions. To say that that is disagreeable is an understatement.

Particularly at bigger lodges, the bustle within the foyer and even within the hallways may be counterproductive to your stress-free getaway plans. If you understand you need to completely disconnect or discover some solitude, there are smaller lodges or ones which have extra personal villas.

Generally costlier

Because the hospitality trade is altering, lodges at the moment are keener on Airbnb’s popularity of being a budget-friendly platform and are adjusting their charges accordingly to compete. Nevertheless, lodges stay costlier than Airbnbs in most locations. Generally you will get a complete condo to your self for cheaper than a cramped lodge room in a big chain lodge, which might flip lots of people off to lodges normally.

Fewer alternatives to get off the crushed path

Since lodges are often in strategic places which are simply accessible to vacationers, it’s not as straightforward to seek out them in additional off-the-beaten-path locations. This isn’t to say it’s unimaginable, although. It’s simply not at all times a assure that you simply’ll discover a lodge in the course of nowhere the identical means you’ll find Airbnbs in these locations.

Not sensible for longer stays

If you understand you’ll be someplace for greater than per week or so, staying at a lodge won’t be the very best thought. Except you discover an “aparthotel” with a kitchen, confining your self to a lodge room means you gained’t have the ability to put together your individual meals. Going out to eating places solely positively provides up.

Are Accommodations Well worth the Worth?

international house hotel new orleans

The reply to this actually is dependent upon what sort of journey expertise you need to have and what your wants are in the case of lodging. In case you’re a first-time solo traveler who is a little more nervous about security, maybe the added safety of a lodge will present a extra worry-free journey. Whereas lodges aren’t at all times costlier than Airbnbs, they often supply much less area in change for higher facilities, security, and repair, which is perhaps price the additional price if these issues are necessary to you.

Pin me for later:

In case you’re an adventurous traveler who needs to keep away from crowds and keep in distinctive locations, Airbnb is perhaps a greater possibility. In case you are extra cautious and need a extra predictable journey expertise, lodges are nice. Placing Airbnb vs. lodge stays head-to-head will look completely different for various sorts of vacationers, however I hope this checklist offers you a greater thought of what’s best for you.

Which do you often favor while you journey? Tell us within the feedback!